Blog

Informal resolution in schools: resolving staff conflict before it escalates

20th November 2026

A mediator in a green shirt and glasses leading a discussion involving multiple staff members.

School workforces rely on a dedicated network of teams to coordinate the daily operations involved in running an educational setting. In an environment that is so dependent on collaboration, occasional misunderstandings or clashes in working styles are completely normal. 

The real challenge for school leaders is knowing how to address these everyday tensions early, calmly, and fairly, so small disagreements are resolved constructively before they turn into formal grievances. 

What is informal resolution?

Informal resolution is a method of resolving a dispute or disagreement effectively through open dialogue. Rather than focusing on who is right and wrong, these conversations are focused on how those involved can work together moving forward. This can take place in the form of:

  • Encouraging members of staff to speak directly about an issue
  • A quick one-to-one where a line manager can listen to concerns and find practical solutions
  • A structured catch-up process with any individuals involved
  • A three-way conversation led by a neutral manager or HR representative to help colleagues clear the air

ACAS guidance encourages informal resolution wherever possible and highlights that addressing minor workplace disagreements early often leads to faster and more lasting outcomes than formal procedures.

Common causes of conflict between school staff

A good place to start with conflict resolution at work is understanding how tensions can build in the first place. In a busy school where teaching and operational teams rely heavily on communication and daily interactions, small points of tension can quickly develop from several common triggers. 

Workload

Tensions can easily arise over cover allocations, lunchtime duties, uneven admin task distributions, or the allocation of work during the busier months of the school year. 

Miscommunication

In a school environment, there can be little chance for a proper catch-up with colleagues between lessons or tasks. This can sometimes manifest as rushed emails or hasty exchanges that don’t convey the right tone. 

Role boundaries and hierarchies

Tensions between teachers and teaching assistants in particular can arise when classroom responsibilities or authority aren’t well-defined. The same can happen with operational and facilities staff members who can be made to feel undervalued or spoken down to.

Differing approaches

This can take the form of clashes over student expectations, different working styles in shared offices, or even resistance to new school-wide systems that disrupt established routines without enough training. 

External stress and burnout

Because pressure heightens during inspection periods, exam seasons, end-of-term deadlines, or when personal life challenges arise, resilience across all staff groups can drop, making colleagues more reactive to minor irritations or inconveniences. 

The benefits of addressing issues early

Working in an educational environment means working with teams that are collaborative and interdependent. This gives school leaders all the more reason to carry out early resolution when minor tensions appear, rather than waiting for a formal complaint to be filed. 

Rather than noticing a small bit of tension between two people and assuming that things will blow over, taking decisive action stops the knock-on effect of wider team disruption and stress-related absence. 

Preserving working relationships means supporting colleagues who share classrooms, offices, or operational routines in working close by one another with a mutual respect. Most importantly, creating a united pupil-facing team is the best way to maintain a calm and consistent school environment for your students. 

Preparing for sensitive a conversation

Before sitting down with staff, taking a little time to plan your approach can be the difference between a constructive chat and a conversation that goes off track. 

Reading up on policies

First, give yourself a refresher on your school’s grievance and staff code of conduct policies prior to anything else. This will ensure that you’re clear on boundaries and what to look out for while preparing for the informal resolution discussion. 

Fact gathering

Your next port of call should be getting the facts of the matter straight. Note down observable behaviours and specific examples and separate this from rumours or comments from those who aren’t involved in the situation.  

 

An employee making notes in a notebook while another employee explains something beside a laptop.

You should be approaching the scenario with genuine curiosity and an objective view, regardless of your existing relationship with the staff involved or any assumptions about who might be at fault. 

Outline an appropriate time and place

Rather than holding the meeting at the end of a busy day or in an area that other staff members frequent, arrange for a dedicated private space to be available during the working day so that nobody feels rushed or keen to get the conversation over and done with. 

Opening the conversation and key points

Draft up a calm and natural opening to the conversation so that you can set things off on the right footing. This shouldn’t be a script to read from, more a few brief notes that you want to touch on at the beginning of the meeting. 

It’s best practice to have some notes of key points that you’d like to cover throughout the meeting too. If a discussion comes to an end, you’ll have something to start things back up again.  

Anticipate emotional reactions

It’s completely normal for staff members to feel defensive or embarrassed throughout the discussion, leading to emotional reactions like crying or becoming unusually quiet and withdrawn. 

Don’t dismiss these moments. It’s quite common for informal resolution meetings to go like this as this can be the employee’s first realisation that they’ve inadvertently upset a colleague. Allow pauses for reflection while keeping the discussion on topic if emotions begin to run high. 

As the mediator in the situation, it is up to you to stay collected and understand when a situation is too serious to handle informally and needs to be escalated. 

Leading a faciliated conversation

Once you have prepared your notes and chosen a private, unhurried time to meet, having a clear structure for the discussion itself will help keep things fair and productive. 

  1. Open the meeting by agreeing simple boundaries. Encourage active listening, respectful communication, focusing on solutions, and keeping the discussion confidential afterwards. 
  2. Encourage each person to share their perspective and their perspective alone. It’s important to discount any second-hand accounts describing an employee’s point of view who isn’t present. 
  3. Remind both colleagues of their shared professional goals and common ground. 
  4. Outline and agree on practical next steps to conclude the meeting on a positive note. 
  5. Book a short follow-up check-in about a month after the initial resolution meeting to confirm that positive progress has been made and allow for any tweaks if required.

The role of managers and school leaders

For school leadership teams, your most important role is in the early identification of an issue. Site Managers, Line Managers, Heads of Year, and Headteachers should be focused on spotting early warning signs amongst teams and knowing when to step in. 

When faced with a complaint about a disagreement between employees, it’s good practice (when appropriate) to offer advice on giving constructive feedback first and support employees in building confidence with handling everyday disagreements.  

It’s your responsibility to remain impartial and demonstrate complete fairness. Give both individuals equal opportunities to speak and avoid taking sides, regardless of seniority, job title, or your working relationship.   

At the same time, leaders must set clear expectations around professional standards and mutual respect. Staff don’t need to be good friends, but they do need to be able to successfully work together. 

When should mediation take place?

Mediation is a form of informal resolution that sits further on the structured side of informal processes. Mediation is appropriate if you have a situation where: 

  • A line manager has already tried an informal chat without any lasting results 
  • Highly interdependent employees need to rebuild broken trust and communication 
  • An impartial mediator with no prior knowledge of either party is needed 
  • Both parties have voluntarily requested it to find their own mutually acceptable way forward 

Unlike a standard management catch-up, mediation is guided by a neutral third-party who helps both sides build their own workable agreement without imposing a solution. 

When should a formal investigation take place?

While informal resolution is effective for everyday misunderstandings and low-level friction, it is not appropriate for every situation. A formal investigation should take place if the situation involves:  

  1. Pupil safety, financial irregularity, gross misconduct, or child protection 
  2. Sexual harassment, victimisation, persistent intimidation, or any other unlawful discrimination under the Equality Act 2010 
  3. Repeat issues where clear agreements have been made but problematic behaviour continues to take place 
  4. Genuine intimidation from a senior colleague 
  5. An employee who is insistent on a formal procedure, as is their contractual right 

Whether this behaviour is then followed up with disciplinary action or something more severe, it’s crucial for employers to be able to discern which kind of approach is proportionate and legally compliant. 

Documenting agreed outcomes without formalities

Firstly, all of your notes should be recorded using factual balanced language rather than subjective commentary or implied blame. 

Note down essential information only. Record the date, attendees, key discussion points, and agreed outcomes.  

Next, send a short and supportive follow-up email summarising the discussion and agreements so that everybody is on the same page. Focus on the commitments made and what each employee should know moving forward so that the document is more of an action plan. 

Always store notes of the calibre in line with General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) and school HR procedures. This should include a clear review date after which the notes can be archived or fully closed if that matter has been resolved. 

Build confidence in every conversation

Minor misunderstandings in the workplace are inevitable. That’s why school leaders should focus on what’s in their control; preventing them from escalating. By spotting the early warning signs and understanding how to hold a productive and supportive informal discussion, school leaders can protect working relationships across their educational environment.  

At Heads HR, we offer an independent perspective and practical, school-focused HR support to help you navigate tricky staff conversations. Whether your unique staff situation calls for an impartial mediator or some further advice on whether an issue requires a formal route, our team is here to help you protect staff wellbeing and maintain a positive school culture.  

Get in touch to discuss how we can support your leadership team with difficult conversations or tailored conflict-resolution training.

Female teacher wearing blue lanyard and smiling directly at camera.

"We have had the pleasure of working with Heads HR for several years and their support has consistently been outstanding. Their depth of knowledge and practical expertise have been invaluable in helping us navigate a wide range of HR matters with confidence. The team is always approachable and it’s reassuring to know there is always someone at the end of the phone or quick to respond via email whenever we need assistance. We highly value the ongoing support they provide and look forward to many more years of working together."

Heyes Lane Primary School logo.

Sally Harkin, Headteacher

Heyes Lane Primary School

"I have used Heads HR for a number of years and have found their support and advice to be invaluable. They are always only a phone call away and I can always trust and know that someone will get back to me promptly if I have a query or an urgent issue to seek advice on. Head's HR have recently supported me through a restructure which made the process so much smoother and easier to manage due to their calm, measured advice and secure knowledge and understanding of policies, processes and procedures. I cannot rate them highly enough due to the clarity they provide; their accessibility and their unwavering support with any issue, large or small."

Davyhulme Primary School.

Kate Brookes, Headteacher

Davyhulme Primary School

Heads HR have provided invaluable HR support for Greave Primary School. Their extensive knowledge of the education sector and round-the-clock availability have enabled the leadership team to swiftly deal with issues in a proactive and informed manner. In addition, the regular updates on current legislation and guidance have ensured we are always fully prepared for any changes. An exceptional, high-quality, reliable service that I can highly recommend.

Greave Primary School logo.

Jennie Williams, Headteacher

Greave Primary School

Heads HR provides pragmatic, workable HR solutions for our school. They are a key part of our school team and are always on hand to provide advice and resolve issues either remotely or at our school. Communication between school and Heads HR is superb; we never have to wait long to get answers to our questions. Heads HR provide excellent support to our school, and we would definitely recommend them.

Joe Barker, Headteacher

Marple Hall School

Discover why schools trust us

What drives us

Our core values

Backed by decades of education expertise, our core values guide how we partner with your school to empower your staff.

Genuine partnership

We work hand-in-hand with your leadership team from day one, acting as a trusted extension of your school.

Tailored to you

We reject one-size-fits-all approaches, delivering practical guidance that respects your unique workplace culture and specific needs.

Grounded in experience

With over 50 years of combined education expertise, we provide calm, authoritative counsel that safeguards your establishment.