Blog

How to handle a staff grievance procedure in a school

23rd October 2026

Young female teacher sits in school cloakroom looking pensive.

When a member of staff’s behaviour falls short of expected professional standards, handling the situation effectively is one of the most challenging responsibilities a school leader and governing board can face. In an environment where every decision is subject to intense scrutiny, navigating staff conduct requires clear procedures, fairness, and a sound understanding of employment law.

The operational pressure on schools to maintain high standards has never been more pronounced. While the Teaching Regulation Agency (TRA) regulates the teaching profession in England and investigates allegations of serious teacher misconduct referred to it, the responsibility falls on the school/employer for investigating and managing disciplinary matters locally, with serious cases potentially being referred to the TRA following completion of the internal process. Recent data highlights the ongoing strain across the education regulatory landscape, with the Teaching Regulation Agency delivering a record-breaking number of conduct hearings, surpassing 320 annually, while managing thousands of historical and incoming referrals. Implementing a transparent and compliant disciplinary procedure within your school or academy has never been more important for resolving issues internally before they escalate externally.

School staff work under unique pressures. The shared commitment to pupils’ wellbeing, high-stakes accountability, and long working hours can result in interpersonal friction and workplace stress. With 37% of education employers reporting a rise in workplace grievances over the past year,managing staff concerns effectively has never been more critical. Unresolved conflicts can impact trust, team collaboration, impact pupil learning, and result in costly employment tribunals.   

This guide provides headteachers, senior leadership teams (SLTs), governors, and school business managers (SBMs) with a structured and sensitive approach to handling staff grievances in line with workplace best practices and ACAS guidelines. 

1. What is a staff grievance?

A grievance is a formal or informal concern or complaint raised by an employee regarding their work, working environment, or working relationships. 

It is important to distinguish between a grievance and other HR processes: 

A grievance is raised by an employee about their treatment or working conditions. 

A disciplinary is action taken by management regarding an employee’s conduct or performance. 

Whistleblowing is a disclosure in the public interest regarding wrongdoing, dangerous activities, or illegal acts. 

A grievance is a mechanism for employees to seek resolution when they feel that standard management conversations have failed or are inappropriate given the nature of the issue. 

2. Common reasons staff raise grievances in schools

Understanding why grievances occur helps leadership teams address root causes early. In educational settings, common drivers include: 

  • Workplace bullying or harassment that makes someone feel intimidated or offended. 
  • Concerns that work pressures are unmanageable or that reasonable adjustments/support have not been provided. 
  • Interpersonal conflicts between department heads, teachers, or support staff that impair working relationships. 
  • Disputes over directed time, flexible working requests, cover allocation, or pay progression decisions. 
  • Perceived unfair treatment during restructuring or performance management. 

3. Informal resolution & formal grievance

Not every complaint requires a full formal grievance procedure. In fact, resolving issues early and informally is generally preferred wherever safe and appropriate. 

When informal resolution is appropriate 

Informal resolution works best for minor misunderstandings and communication failures, or early-stage interpersonal friction. 

Your approach should be to arrange an informal meeting between the employee and their line manager (or another senior colleague if the manager is involved). 

Lady with glasses takes notes while listening to colleague in spacious room of school with red and white wall in background.

This informal setting requires open dialogue or facilitated discussions. The goal is to find a mutually agreed path forward without logging a formal outcome on employee records. 

When a formal process is needed 

A formal procedure must be initiated when:

  • The employee explicitly requests a formal grievance process 
  • Informal attempts have failed or the relationship continues to deteriorate 
  • The allegations are serious (e.g., severe bullying, harassment, discrimination, or fraud) 
  • There are potential legal implications or safeguarding concerns 

4. Receiving and acknowledging a grievance

How a school responds in the first 48 to 72 hours sets the tone for the entire process. A defensive or delayed response damages trust immediately. 

You should: 

  • Request that the employee submit their grievance in writing, clearly detailing the facts, dates, named individuals, and desired outcome. 
  • Send a formal letter acknowledging receipt within 2 to 5 working days. 
  • Ask the employee what resolution they are seeking (e.g., an apology, a change in process, mediation). 
  • Make sure the person designated to hear the grievance is impartial and not directly implicated in the complaint. If the grievance involves the Headteacher, the Chair of Governors must oversee the process. 

5. Investigating concerns fairly

A thorough and neutral investigation is the backbone of a fair grievance process. 

Appointing an investigator 

Choose an investigator who is trained, objective, and has no prior involvement in the dispute. For complex grievances involving senior leaders or governors, commissioning an independent external investigator is strongly recommended. 

 Key investigation principles: 

  • Remind all parties, including witnesses, that discussions are strictly confidential. 
  • Collect relevant emails, meeting notes, policies, cover sheets, or performance logs. 
  • Interview witnesses separately. Focus strictly on factual evidence rather than staff gossip. 
  • The investigator produces an objective report summarising the evidence to help the hearing panel make an informed decision. 

6. Holding a grievance meeting

Once the investigation is complete, invite the employee to a formal grievance hearing. You will need to provide reasonable written notice, and the employee has a statutory right to be accompanied by a trade representative or work colleague.  

Within the grievance meeting, the employee explains their grievance and presents their evidence. The panel or manager then asks questions based on the investigation and the employee summarises their points.  

Communicating the decision 

Following the meeting, the decision maker considers all evidence and decides whether to uphold, partially uphold, or reject the grievance. 

 The written outcome decision should be issued without undue delay and needs to explain the reasoning clearly, outlining any remedial actions or recommendations, and providing details on how to appeal. 

7. The right to appeal

Every employee has the statutory right to appeal a grievance outcome if they feel the process was flawed, unreasonable, or new evidence has come to light. 

Managing appeals 

The employee has a set period from receiving the outcome letter to submit an appeal in writing, stating their grounds. It must be heard by someone senior to the original decision maker, and they need to have not been involved previously (for example, a panel of governors). 

The appeal decision is final within the school’s internal procedures.  

8. Common mistakes schools should avoid

Managing grievances in schools carries unique risk factors. To protect school culture and minimise risk, leaders should avoid these five critical pitfalls: 

1. Delaying action 

Dragging out timelines increases staff stress, damages morale, and risks constructive dismissal claims. 

Stick strictly to your policy timeframes and communicate any unavoidable delays immediately in writing. 

2. Breaching confidentiality 

In close-knit school teams, leaks cause internal division and damage witness statements. It’s important to remind all participants in writing of their statutory duty of confidentiality. 

3. Showing bias 

Expressing early opinions or pre-judging outcomes undermines the procedural fairness of the investigation. Participants need to maintain strict objectivity and not make any conclusions until all evidence has been reviewed. 

4. Confusing grievances with disciplinary action 

Attempting to use a grievance procedure to penalise a manager (or vice versa) will invalidate the process. 

A grievance outcome may recommend a separate disciplinary process, but it cannot replace one.

5. Failing to support parties post-outcome 

Assuming the issue is resolved once the formal outcome letter is delivered often leads to secondary grievances. It’s important to implement a structured plan to repair working relationships and successfully reintegrate staff.  

How Heads HR supports school leaders

Heads HR provides specialist, education-focused HR advice and support to help school leaders handle grievances with confidence.  

We can support you with: 

  • Reviewing policies and making sure your grievance and dignity at work documents are compliant with current ACAS codes and DfE guidance. 
  • Providing impartial, experienced investigators to conduct reviews of complex or high-risk grievances.  
  • Step-by-step guidance for Headteachers and SBMs on drafting letters, structuring investigation reports, and conducting hearings. 
  • Expert support during grievance and appeal hearings to ensure procedural accuracy. 
  • Acting as a mediator during informal processes before they escalate to formal grievances. 

Handling a staff grievance fairly and sensitively is essential for maintaining trust and a positive school culture. By following established procedures and seeking specialist HR guidance when needed, school leaders can resolve issues constructively while protecting both staff wellbeing and the school’s reputation.

Female teacher wearing blue lanyard and smiling directly at camera.

"We have had the pleasure of working with Heads HR for several years and their support has consistently been outstanding. Their depth of knowledge and practical expertise have been invaluable in helping us navigate a wide range of HR matters with confidence. The team is always approachable and it’s reassuring to know there is always someone at the end of the phone or quick to respond via email whenever we need assistance. We highly value the ongoing support they provide and look forward to many more years of working together."

Heyes Lane Primary School logo.

Sally Harkin, Headteacher

Heyes Lane Primary School

"I have used Heads HR for a number of years and have found their support and advice to be invaluable. They are always only a phone call away and I can always trust and know that someone will get back to me promptly if I have a query or an urgent issue to seek advice on. Head's HR have recently supported me through a restructure which made the process so much smoother and easier to manage due to their calm, measured advice and secure knowledge and understanding of policies, processes and procedures. I cannot rate them highly enough due to the clarity they provide; their accessibility and their unwavering support with any issue, large or small."

Davyhulme Primary School.

Kate Brookes, Headteacher

Davyhulme Primary School

Heads HR have provided invaluable HR support for Greave Primary School. Their extensive knowledge of the education sector and round-the-clock availability have enabled the leadership team to swiftly deal with issues in a proactive and informed manner. In addition, the regular updates on current legislation and guidance have ensured we are always fully prepared for any changes. An exceptional, high-quality, reliable service that I can highly recommend.

Greave Primary School logo.

Jennie Williams, Headteacher

Greave Primary School

Heads HR provides pragmatic, workable HR solutions for our school. They are a key part of our school team and are always on hand to provide advice and resolve issues either remotely or at our school. Communication between school and Heads HR is superb; we never have to wait long to get answers to our questions. Heads HR provide excellent support to our school, and we would definitely recommend them.

Joe Barker, Headteacher

Marple Hall School

Discover why schools trust us

What drives us

Our core values

Backed by decades of education expertise, our core values guide how we partner with your school to empower your staff.

Genuine partnership

We work hand-in-hand with your leadership team from day one, acting as a trusted extension of your school.

Tailored to you

We reject one-size-fits-all approaches, delivering practical guidance that respects your unique workplace culture and specific needs.

Grounded in experience

With over 50 years of combined education expertise, we provide calm, authoritative counsel that safeguards your establishment.